Tuesday, October 30, 2018

Answering the question "Who am I" in the age of identity politics

Who am I?  It’s a fundamental question that we all ask ourselves at some point.  Who am I – really?  What does it mean to be me?  It’s a question that needs to be answered as we are growing up and maturing and trying to discover our purpose and our passion.  We need to understand what makes us unique.  We need to understand our gifts and talents and all the things that have prepared us to do the thing that we were created to do.

So, it’s no surprise that we begin to define ourselves by those characteristics that make us unique.  When asked who we are, we say things like:  “I am a woman.  I am Caucasian.  I am a Christian.  I am an introverted math nerd.  I am a teacher.  I am a musician.  I am a good cook.  I am a mom.  I am a wife.”  You get the picture.

But here’s the problem.  When we begin to find our identity – our self worth – our value as a person – in those characteristics that we use to define ourselves, we can begin to lose sight of the things that bind us together with everyone else on the planet.  When we identify more strongly with the things that make us different than everyone else – our gender, our race, our religion, our sexual orientation, our political preference – than with the things that make us the same, we understandably begin to take it very personally when we see or hear things that question or demean or criticize or disagree with these characteristics.

Don’t get me wrong – I am in no way saying it’s right or ok for anyone to hurt you or put you down or treat you as “less than” because of the things that make you uniquely you.  In fact, I abhor the hateful rhetoric that seems to plague our country these days.  But, what I AM saying is that, while you can’t control the rhetoric, you CAN control how you react to it.

When your identity is bound up in your gender or race or sexual orientation, it’s not a surprise that you feel every hateful word and action as if it’s a personal attack on WHO YOU ARE.  If the thing that I identify with most strongly is being a woman, then I feel every demeaning comment made about women on social media as if it were directed at me. I feel like I have personally been overlooked or undervalued when I see another woman being passed over for a promotion.  I feel these things even if they haven’t been part of my experience.  I feel these things a hundred times over if they have.

As long as we live in a fallen world, we can’t change the fact that there are hateful people in the world who will do horrible hateful things and spew horrible hateful words every time they get the chance.  Unfortunately, “evil” is just as much of a reality as “good.”  But, the more that I’ve thought about this, the more that I believe that the way to neutralize the rhetoric is to realize where our true identity lies.  If we know that our true identity is NOT found in our gender or our race or our political preference, then when the hateful words come, we don’t feel it as a personal attack on who we are.  

For example – Suppose that you are driving down the road and see a car run a red light and hit another car.  You will be shocked – upset – concerned.  You might call the police or even stop to help.  But, your reaction will be calm and your focus will be on the person who was hit by the car.  Now, suppose that you are the person in the intersection, and a car runs a red light and hits your car.  Not only will you be shocked and upset – you will probably be angry and irritated and worried.  Once you find out that you are ok, your attention will turn to making sure that the person who hit you pays for the damages and that your car gets fixed.  You are on the defensive and you are focused on protecting you.

While it may be a bit of an oversimplification, the same idea applies when we see someone say something offensive about a woman or a person of color or a homosexual person.  If your identity is bound up in that aspect of your being, then you take those comments personally.  You become angry and upset and defensive.  Something rises up in you that wants to lash out at that person and everyone “like them.”  But, if your identity is found in something bigger – something more universal – then your reaction can be different because it comes from a different place.  You feel the sting of those words.  You have compassion for the one who is being mistreated.  You desire to see justice and do everything you can to defend that person who was wronged.  But your reaction comes from a different place.  It comes from a place of proactively reaching out to help and serve others rather than defensively trying to protect yourself. 

So, back to the age old question – Who am I?  Who am I, really?  Where does my worth come from?  For me, the answer is Jesus.  I know He loves me – He loves me so much that He gave His life for me.  I am valuable because He created me.  Before I was even born, He had a plan and a purpose for me.  And, nothing that anyone says or does can change that.  I am confident in my identity – even when the good ole boys network passes me by for the promotion year after year – even when the man on the street catcalls when I walk by – even when I see people in leadership demean and ridicule women.  Does it bother me when I see those things?  Yes.  Do I want to help and defend women?  Yes.  Do I take it personally and feel like I am “less than” because of those things?  No. Do I become angry and defensive? No.  Do I lash out with hateful words of my own?  No – because at my core, I know who I am.  And, who I am is defined by love, not hate.  Who I am is defined by compassion, not revenge.  Who I am is more concerned with serving others than defending myself or being “right.”

And, even if your worldview is different than mine, you can still lead with love – You can still look for the things that make all of us the same rather than focusing so much on the things that make us different.  It doesn’t mean that we can’t celebrate our diversity – We should!  But, if we can shift our perspective even a few degrees so that our focus is on loving and serving others rather than protecting and defending ourselves, I believe that the world would be a better place…